Drugstore Makeup Picks That Punch Above Their Price

You don't have to spend a lot to get makeup that works. The drugstore aisle is full of pleasant surprises, but also plenty of duds. The trick is knowing which ones actually deliver. That is what this list is for.

These six products scored highest in our reviews. We drew on specs, product details, and patterns in verified buyer feedback. Nobody here tested them physically, but the numbers and owner reports speak clearly. Here they are, ranked from best to still-great.

#ProductBest atShopper rating
1e.l.f. Cream Glide Lip LinerBest overall4.6 / 5
2Revlon ColorStay EyelinerBest for oily lids4.5 / 5
3L'Oreal Infallible Setting SprayBest setting spray for oily skin4.5 / 5
4Maybelline Sky High MascaraBest for length4.5 / 5
5essence Lash Princess MascaraBest for volume on a budget4.3 / 5
6UCANBE Athena PaletteBest for costume and Halloween4.5 / 5
e.l.f. Cream Glide Lip Liner
Best overall

1. e.l.f. Cream Glide Lip Liner

Shopper rating 4.6 / 5 · Budget

The e.l.f. Cream Glide Lip Liner is the top pick because it nails the basics. It glides on without tugging, the semi-matte finish looks natural, and the price is absurdly low. Buyers rave about the pigmentation. The trade off is durability. It is creamy, so a heavy meal means a touch up. You will also need a sharpener, since it is a wooden pencil. Skip it if you need a liner that survives a 12 hour shift without help. For everyday wear, this is unbeatable.

  • Price
  • Texture
  • Durability
Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner
Best for oily lids

2. Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner

Shopper rating 4.5 / 5 · Mid-range

The Revlon ColorStay Eyeliner handles oily eyelids better than most. Owners report it holds 10 plus hours without smudging, even on sweaty walks. The two pack is a nice bonus. But the pencil can feel stiff at first, and removal requires an oil based remover. Do not buy this for precise wings. The tip is too thick for that. If you want a liner that stays put and lets you smudge it for a softer look, this is your pick.

  • Lasts all day
  • Great value for two
  • Requires an oil-based remover
L'Oreal Infallible Setting Spray
Best setting spray for oily skin

3. L'Oreal Infallible Setting Spray

Shopper rating 4.5 / 5 · Mid-range

The L'Oreal Infallible Setting Spray gives 10 to 12 hours of wear without your foundation migrating. It dries fast and leaves no white cast. Buyers with oily skin love how it stalls shine. The catch is the nozzle. Some bottles mist beautifully, others spit. The scent is a bit chemical at first, but it fades quickly. Skip this if you are sensitive to smells. For the price, it does 90 percent of what expensive sprays do.

  • Hold is impressive for the price. You get 10 to 12 hours of…
  • Dries quickly. You don't have to stand there waiting. Spray,…
  • Nozzle quality is inconsistent. Some bottles mist beautifully.…
Maybelline Sky High Mascara
Best for length

4. Maybelline Sky High Mascara

Shopper rating 4.5 / 5 · Budget

The Maybelline Sky High Mascara makes short lashes look longer in one coat. The flexible wand catches every lash, even the tiny inner corner ones. It stays put through a workday without flaking. The volume is modest, so do not expect dramatic thickness. It also dries out faster than average, about two months. If you want natural definition and easy removal, this is a solid buy. If you want dense, fluffy lashes, look elsewhere.

  • Noticeable length
  • Flexible wand reaches every lash
  • Volume is modest
essence Lash Princess Mascara
Best for volume on a budget

5. essence Lash Princess Mascara

Shopper rating 4.3 / 5 · Budget

The essence Lash Princess Mascara gives dramatic volume for about the cost of a coffee. The deep black color is so saturated it replaces eyeliner. The waterproof version holds curl well. The formula is wet, so you need patience between coats, and three coats can clump. Removal is a chore. Skip this if you hate oil based removers. If you want lashes people notice without spending much, this is it.

  • Dramatic volume on a budget
  • Deep black color
  • Wet formula requires patience
UCANBE Athena Palette
Best for costume and Halloween

6. UCANBE Athena Palette

Shopper rating 4.5 / 5 · Budget

The UCANBE Athena Palette packs 20 vibrant colors for an absurdly low price. The oil base blends easily and gives full opacity. It is great for Halloween or cosplay. The downsides: it stays tacky without setting powder, and removal requires an oil based cleanser. Bright colors can stain skin for a day or two. Skip this for daily wear. For a weekend costume project, it covers everything you need.

  • Incredible value
  • Easy blending
  • Stays tacky

Which one should you get?

Think about what matters most to you. If you want one product that does everything well, start with the e.l.f. lip liner. If you need a mascara that adds length without fuss, the Maybelline Sky High is a smarter choice than the essence if you hate difficult removal. For oily skin, the Revlon eyeliner and L'Oreal spray are a strong duo.

How we picked

We ranked the 11 products we have reviewed in this category. Average shopper rating carries the most weight, followed by the value and ease-of-use scores from each review. Where two versions of the same product scored well, we kept one. Our reviews are research-based: they draw on specifications and verified buyer feedback, not lab testing. A product with very few ratings does not get extra credit for a perfect score.

Browse all 11 reviews in Makeup & Beauty