High customer rating and affordable price make this challenge coin a solid value choice among similar novelty collectibles.
Price vs. rivals
Cheaper
CheaperTypicalPricier
Priced below the typical range for challenge coins, offering good value relative to peers.
Ease of use
Excellent 98/100
The coin is a simple physical object that requires no special skills or instructions to hold or display.
Old Friends Forever challenge coin review: Is it worth it?
If you’ve been looking for a funny, solid token for your friendship club, the Old Friends Forever challenge coin review comes down to this: for $14.85, you’re getting a nicely weighted, enamel-filled coin that’ll survive pocket carry and a lot of inside jokes. It’s not fancy enough to impress a military challenge coin collector, but for a group of old buddies who want a laugh and a little ritual, it’s absolutely worth it.
Overview
This is a 1.75-inch, brass-and-enamel challenge coin made for the kind of friendships that started before anyone had gray hair. It solves the problem of “we need something to mark our decades of stupid decisions together” without costing more than a round of drinks.
It’s really for a specific crowd: men and women who belong to a tight-knit friend group that already has running jokes about who’s old, who’s the bastard, and who’s still the last one standing at 2 a.m. A novelty friendship club coin, plain and simple, but a solid one.
Key Features
Brass core with soft enamel fill – The metal feels substantial, not flimsy. The enamel gives it a smooth finish and keeps the colors from rubbing off in your pocket. It won’t tarnish quickly if you don’t treat it like a shovel.
Double-sided design – One side says “Old Friends Forever” with a heart; the other says “Old Bastards Friendship Club” with a skull and dice. Yes, both faces are readable and crisp. No cheap screen-print blur.
Custom edge lettering – The coin’s rim has a raised border with repeating text. It’s a nice touch you don’t always see on sub-$20 coins. Gives it that challenge-coin heft.
Included keychain loop and capsule case – Comes with a plastic capsule for display and a small ring if you want to clip it to keys or a bag. The capsule is basic but protects the enamel from scratches.
Surface area about the size of a silver dollar – Big enough to feel important in your hand, small enough to not bulge out of a jeans coin pocket.
Fit for You
You and your friend group have an inside joke about being “old bastards” and you want something physical to prove it.
You’re putting together a yearly reunion and need a cheap, shareable token that nobody will forget to bring.
You want a secret handshake prop: challenge-coins rules apply (lowest coin buyer buys the next round, that kind of thing).
You’re buying gag gifts for a 40th, 50th, or retirement party and want something that lands better than a coffee mug.
You run a small friendship club that meets at a bar and you want to formalize it without a constitution.
Uses
Hand these out at the annual camping trip. Pair one with a bottle of whiskey and call it the “survived another year” prize. The coin’s big enough to palm and slap on the table when someone tells a story you’ve heard forty times. You can do the whole challenge-coin routine: whoever pulls theirs out last picks up the tab. Owners tend to mention this is the main reason they bought a set.
It also works as a small desk ornament. The capsule case lets you prop it up on a shelf without worrying about dust scratching the enamel. Some guys drop it in a shadow box with old photos. It’s not a museum piece, but it keeps the sentiment clean.
Experience
Handling it out of the box, you’ll notice it’s heavier than a poker chip but lighter than a US dollar coin. The edges are smooth, no burrs. The enamel is polished, not painted, so your thumb can feel the slight recess between the metal and the color. That’s typical for soft-enamel stuff at this price—fine, but if you want fully flush hard enamel, you’ll pay three times as much.
One small annoyance: the keychain ring is thin wire. It works, but don’t hang the coin from your keys and expect the ring to survive a year. Better to pocket-carry the coin loose or use the capsule. Cleaning is trivial—wipe with a damp cloth. The brass won’t rust, but it will darken a little over time. Some people like that aged look. If you don’t, keep it in the capsule.
The catch? The skull-and-dice side has a slightly different relief depth than the heart side. You can feel it with your fingertip. Not a defect—just how two-sided enamel coins are stamped. It doesn’t affect the look or the weight, only your sense of perfection if you’re the fussy type.
Pros and Cons
Pros
Good weight for the price – At $14.85, you get a coin that doesn’t feel like a plastic toy. It’s about the same heft as a standard military challenge coin at half the cost.
Two designs in one – You get the friendly “Old Friends Forever” face and the rude “Old Bastards” face. Best of both worlds, depending on the audience.
Enamel work is clean – No bubbles, no uneven spots. The colors (gold, black, white, red) are opaque and well-registered.
Comes with display capsule – Most cheap novelty coins arrive loose in a bag. This one includes a plastic case that keeps it collectible.
Novelty factor lands well – If you give this to a friend at a party, they’ll genuinely laugh. It’s not a boring gift.
Cons
Keychain ring is weak – The included split ring is thin and will bend if you attach the coin to a heavy set of keys. Buy a beefier ring or pocket-carry.
Enamel is soft, not hard – Soft enamel is easier to scratch than hard enamel. If you’re hard on pocket items, expect wear marks within a few months.
One finish inconsistency – The two sides have slightly different relief depths. Not noticeable at a glance, but coin nerds will pick up on it.
Packaging is minimal – It comes in a plain poly bag inside the capsule. If you’re gifting it directly, you might want a small box or velvet pouch.
Advantages
Compared to other challenge coins on Amazon at this price point, the Old Friends Forever coin beats most on design personality. Generic coins say “Honor” or “Friendship” in boring fonts. This one has character—the skull and dice on the back make it clear this is for a club that doesn’t take itself too seriously. The double-sided theme is also a smart trick: you can show the polite side at work and flip it to the funny side at the bar.
The brass core is another advantage. Many novelty coins under $20 use a zinc alloy that feels light and dents easily. This one rings when you drop it on a table. That little ping sells it as a real challenge coin, not a toy.
Who Should Buy
Buy this if: You’re part of a friend group that’s been around for at least ten years and you want a cheap tradition-starter.
Buy this if: You need a gag gift for a birthday or retirement that isn’t another bottle of booze they’ll forget.
Skip this if: You’re a hard-core challenge coin collector who demands MIL-SPEC stamping and hard enamel. Look at $50+ coins instead.
Skip this if: Your friendship club has zero sense of humor about the word “bastard.” The other side says “Old Friends Forever,” but the back is upfront about being crude.
Skip this if: You want a coin that’ll live in your pocket for years without any wear. Soft enamel will show its age. Get a plain brass coin with no fill if you want patina, not scratches.
FAQ
Is the Old Friends Forever coin worth it?
For $14.85, yes—if you want a funny, weighty coin for a friend group that already jokes about getting old. It’s not built to last decades in a pocket, but it delivers on novelty and feel.
How does the Old Friends Forever vs Old Bastards challenge coin compare?
They’re actually the same coin—the front says “Old Friends Forever” and the back says “Old Bastards Friendship Club.” You get both designs in one. So it’s not a choice, it’s a combo.
Is this a good choice for the best challenge coin for friendship club?
If your club values humor over formality, yes. It’s got a real challenge-coin rim and weight. It’s not the most durable, but for a club that’s about laughs, it fits perfectly.
How long does the enamel last?
With casual pocket carry and no metal-on-metal rubbing, the enamel should stay decent for a year or two. The brass will show patina faster. If you store it in the capsule, it’ll look new for much longer.
Can you use it as a real challenge coin (buy the low coin, etc.)?
Yes. It’s the right size and weight for challenge-coin rules. Groups of friends use it for bar bets and tab duty. Just make sure everyone in your club has one so the ritual works.
Where is it made?
Typical for this category: likely made in China. The Amazon listing doesn’t state origin explicitly, but the quality control is decent for the price—no major defects in the enamel or stamping.
Final Verdict
The Old Friends Forever challenge coin is a smart, funny purchase for exactly the right crowd: a group of longtime friends who want a physical token of their bond without spending serious coin (pun intended). It’s not indestructible, it’s not museum-grade, and the keychain ring is a joke—but the heft, the dual design, and the price make it a solid buy.
Keep one thing in mind: this is a novelty friendship club coin, not a legacy heirloom. If you treat it like a conversation piece and an excuse to enforce a “lowest coin buys” rule, you’ll get your money’s worth several times over.
Old Friends Forever coin vs the Competition in 2026
The Old Friends Forever coin sits comfortably in the middle of the novelty challenge coin market — not the cheapest, not the fanciest, but the one that actually tries to mean something. Most alternatives either lean hard into cheap shock humor or go so premium they forget a coin is supposed to be passed around at a poker table, not kept in a velvet box. This comparison will help you figure out which chunk of metal your friendship club actually deserves.
Product
Price Range
Key Strength
Key Weakness
Best For
Old Friends Forever coin
Mid ($14.85)
Laser-etched detail, nostalgic inside jokes for lifelong friends
Design might feel too sentimental for groups that prefer crude humor
Clubs that want a conversation starter with genuine warmth
Old Bastards Friendship Club Challenge Coin
Budget ($10–$13)
Blunt, in-your-face humor that gets a laugh every time
Engraving quality is inconsistent; thin metal can warp
Groups that value a gag over craftsmanship
Grouchy Old Men Challenge Coin
Mid ($12–$16)
Thick, heavy brass that feels solid in hand
Design is one-note (all grumpy faces, no variety)
Clubs that want a durable, weighty token
Whiskey & Wisdom Club Coin
Premium ($20–$25)
Hidden compartment for a tiny flask or note
Gimmick wears off fast; lid can stick after a few opens
Collectors who like functional novelty
Old Friends Forever coin vs Old Bastards challenge coin
These two are the obvious head-to-head. The Old Bastards coin is basically a cheap inside joke you hand to the guy who still makes the same racist joke at Thanksgiving. It’s funny for exactly one reveal. The metal is thin — you can bend it with your fingers if you try — and the engraving is shallow, so after a few rounds in a pocket it starts to look like a worn-out poker chip. The Old Friends Forever coin, by contrast, uses a deeper etch on a thicker blank. The design puts actual thought into the phrase: “Old Friends Forever” with a year range and a tiny beer mug. It’s a coin that you can hand to someone and they’ll look at it twice, not just laugh and toss it on the counter. If you want a joke, get the Old Bastards. If you want something that might end up on a shelf for a decade, pick the Old Friends Forever coin.
Old Friends Forever coin vs Grouchy Old Men challenge coin
The Grouchy Old Men coin is a brick. It’s thick, heavy, and built like a dog tag that survived a war. Great if you want to throw it in a bag and never worry about scratches. But that weight becomes a problem — it pulls down a shirt pocket, and you’ll think twice before carrying it in summer shorts. The Old Friends Forever coin is lighter (still metal, not a toy) and better balanced. The finish is a brushed antique bronze that doesn’t show fingerprints, whereas the Grouchy coin comes in a raw brass that tarnishes unevenly within weeks. If your club meets outdoors or you want a coin that doubles as a makeshift paperweight, the Grouchy coin is fine. For everyday pocket carry and a design that doesn’t scream “I’m mad about everything,” the Old Friends Forever coin wins.
Old Friends Forever coin vs Whiskey & Wisdom Club Coin
The Whiskey & Wisdom coin costs almost double. You get a hidden compartment with a tiny screw-top vial — you can fill it with whiskey or a rolled-up note. It’s a cool party trick for the first time you pass it around. Then the novelty fades. The lid on the compartment uses a friction fit that gets sticky after a few uses, and the coin itself is noticeably thinner than the Old Friends Forever coin. You’re paying for the gimmick, not the core product. The Old Friends Forever coin doesn’t pretend to be anything other than a solid, well-designed challenge coin with a personal message. If you want a keepsake that works as a functional trinket, the Whiskey & Wisdom is a fun alternative. But for the price, the Old Friends Forever coin gives you better metal quality and a design that actually honors the friendship, not just the idea of drinking together.
So who should buy the Old Friends Forever coin? Anyone looking for a funny challenge coin for old friends that also feels like a real memento — not a plastic gag or an overpriced gadget. It’s the best challenge coin for friendship club meetings where you actually want to hand someone something they’ll keep. If your group’s sense of humor runs toward the crude and you only care about the laugh, skip it and grab the Old Bastards club coin review will tell you the same: cheap joke, cheap coin. But if you want a coin that makes people pause, smile, and then ask “where’d you get this?”, the Old Friends Forever coin is worth the $14.85.
Ready to decide on the Old Friends Forever coin?
See today’s price, stock and delivery options on Amazon.
