This Earth Rated poop bags review gets straight to it: yes, they’re worth it for most dog owners. The lavender scent keeps the odor manageable, the rolls are easy to load, and 270 bags at $14.99 is a decent price for a bag that doesn’t rip. Just don’t expect magic.
Excellent value for a well-rated, scented brand offering a large quantity at a reasonable per-bag cost.
Price vs. rivals
Pricier
CheaperTypicalPricier
Priced slightly above most standard unscented poop bag refills, reflecting the premium for lavender-scented, thicker material and a highly rated brand.
Ease of use
Excellent 95/100
These refill rolls are straightforward to tear off and use, making cleanup easy for any dog owner.
Overview: Earth Rated Poop Bags Review
Earth Rated makes dog poop bags the boring way, and that’s a compliment. They’re thick, scented enough, and they don’t surprise you. This listing is for Earth Rated poop bags refill rolls 270 total, in lavender, and it solves the two real problems in this category: bags that rip at the worst moment, and bags that don’t do anything about the smell.
Who is it really for? Anyone who walks a dog on a normal schedule and doesn’t want to think about the bag. It’s not a fancy gadget. It’s a supply buy. And for the price of a couple of coffees, you’re set for months.
Key Features: Earth Rated Poop Bags Review
These aren’t complicated products, so there are only a few details that matter. Here’s what you get.
Lavender scent – The Earth Rated lavender scented poop bags do what the name says. The perfume is noticeable on the bag, not just at the tie, and it takes the edge off the worst part of the walk. If you’re comparing the best dog poop bags for odor control, that alone puts this roll on the shortlist.
Leak-proof construction – Are Earth Rated poop bags leak proof? In normal use, yes. The seams and material hold up when you’re hauling a full bag to the bin. No extra layers, just a thicker bag than the cheap stuff.
Clean perforations – You can tear one bag off with one hand while holding a leash with the other. It sounds like a small thing until you try it with a roll that wants to rip sideways.
Refill roll format – Each roll fits standard dispensers, and the rolls stack neatly in a drawer. This is exactly the convenience of Earth Rated poop bags refill rolls 270 count without a bulky box in your way.
Fair price – At $14.99 for 270, you’re paying about five and a half cents per bag. That buys a better feel and a scent, which puts it in the middle-upper range among everyday bags.
Fit for You
Here are the situations where this purchase feels smarter than a random roll of bags.
You take the dog out before coffee and don’t want to start the day with a gag-reflex test.
You live in a building where the walk from doorstep to trash chute is a gauntlet of neighbours and bad smells.
You have a big dog and would rather not handle a split bag with your bare hand on a public sidewalk.
You’d rather buy a supply once and forget for a couple of months than keep a running list of pet supplies.
You use a leash-side dispenser and want a roll that drops in without a wrestling match.
Uses
The main event is the mid-walk pickup on a street full of witnesses. You tear off a bag, cover your hand with the roll, bend down, and do the little twist-and-pull. The lavender scent is doing quiet work here, especially when the sun has been on the pavement all afternoon.
These are also the bags you keep in the car for road trips. A dog that drinks too much water at a rest stop can leave a bigger cleanup than you planned, with no trash can in sight. A roll in the glovebox takes care of it.
Backyard duty is another one. If you do a daily sweep before letting the kids out, a refill roll next to the back door beats carrying a loose bag through the house.
Experience
Living with these boils down to a few small routines. The box holds the whole supply as compact rolls, so you load one into a dispenser and keep the rest in a basket. The first bag on a fresh roll is the only fiddly moment, because the leading edge can fold over before you anchor it.
On the walk, the bag opens easily. No huffing and puffing to spread the mouth. After the pickup, the lavender does its best to hold the odor until you reach a bin. It doesn’t vanish, but the sharp edge goes away.
Storage is a little more noticeable than a single roll. A 270-count supply takes a modest spot in a drawer or hall closet, just not in a coat pocket.
One thing to expect: the scent is on everything it touches. If you keep the rolls in a bag with your gloves, your gloves will smell faintly of lavender. Some people like that. Others might find it surprising.
Pros and Cons
Pros
Scent that does something – The lavender masks the sharp smell instead of just adding perfume. It makes the carry to the bin less gross.
Dependable material – The seams hold and the bag doesn’t stretch into a weird shape when it’s full. That’s the difference between this and a flimsy roll.
Clean tear – The perforation separates sharply, so you’re not wrestling one bag out of a crumpled roll.
Good math – $14.99 for 270 bags is a fair rate for the quality. You’re not paying luxury prices.
Wide compatibility – These fit standard dispensers, which is more than some no-name rolls do.
Cons
Scent is not optional – The lavender is right there on the bag, and it transfers to your hands a little. If you don’t like lavender, pick the unscented version.
Cheaper alternatives exist – Amazon Basics and similar brands cost less per bag. You’re paying for the thickness and the scent, and that’s a fair but real trade-off.
Bulk storage – A 270-count supply is great until you need a place to keep it. It won’t hide in a coat pocket.
Not sharp-object-proof – A thorn or edge can still puncture any bag. These are sturdy, not indestructible.
Advantages
The Earth Rated vs Amazon Basics poop bags comparison keeps coming up because both are popular buys. Amazon Basics gets you a lower price and a functional bag. Earth Rated gives you a thicker feel and a scent that actually helps. If your walk is short and cold, the cheap bag is fine. If it’s warm and close, the extra few cents make a visible difference.
The Earth Rated poop bags review would be incomplete without mentioning the 4.8-star average on Amazon. That rating is backed by the two things people actually care about: smell and strength. It’s not a weird feature list that looks good on a box but fails on a walk.
Who Should Buy
If you’re on the fence, here’s the short version.
Buy it if you want a box of bags that will last through two months of daily walks without restocking.
Buy it if you’re tired of holding a tied bag close to your face while you walk to the bin.
Buy it if you use a standard dispenser and appreciate a roll that loads without a fight.
Skip it if you need compostable bags; look for a certified compostable option instead.
Skip it if price is the only deciding factor; a cheaper roll will work, just without the scent and the thicker feel.
FAQ
These are the questions that usually come up.
Is Earth Rated poop bags worth it?
Yes, for most dog owners. You’re paying a few cents more per bag than a bottom-shelf roll, and you get a thicker feel and a scent that keeps the walk civil. If you’ve ever handled a torn bag on a busy street, that upgrade pays for itself quickly.
How long does 270 bags last?
For a single average dog, 270 bags lasts roughly two to three months if you walk once or twice a day. If your dog is small and uses a yard sometimes, it stretches further. Keep the box near the door and you won’t think about it.
Are Earth Rated poop bags leak proof?
In ordinary use, yes. The seams hold, the material doesn’t stretch out when you lift a heavy load, and you can tie the bag without poking a hole. No poop bag is invincible against tree branches, but these handle the daily walk without drama.
Does the lavender scent really work?
It doesn’t make the smell disappear entirely. What it does is cut the sharp, sour note that makes carrying a bag unpleasant. On a warm day, you’ll still know what’s inside, but your hand won’t be in the direct line of it.
Are these bags compostable?
This particular box, the regular lavender refill rolls, isn’t labeled as compostable. If you need bags that go into a compost pile, check the label and look for the certified compostable version. Don’t toss this roll into a composter and expect it to break down.
Do these fit a standard dispenser?
Yes. The rolls are sized like the usual refill rolls, so they’ll sit in most leash-side dispensers. The cardboard core is solid, and the perforation between bags is clean enough to tear one-handed while holding a leash. You don’t need a special carrier, and the roll stays put while you pull.
Final Verdict: Earth Rated Poop Bags Review
This Earth Rated poop bags review has a simple bottom line: buy the lavender rolls if you want a dependable, odor-masking bag that won’t make you dread the walk. The price is fair, the roll format is convenient, and the scent does its job.
So, is Earth Rated poop bags worth it? Yes, with one caveat. It’s still a disposable plastic bag, and it’s not compostable. If that’s okay with you, this is one of the best dog poop bags for odor control you can order without overthinking.
If you’re searching for the best dog poop bags for odor control, Earth Rated’s lavender-scented rolls are a common first stop. They’re priced in the middle of the pack—around $15 for 270 bags—and they hold a 4.8-star average. But that rating doesn’t tell you whether they’re actually worth it for your daily walk, your trash can, or your tolerance for scented plastic. Below I’ve lined them up against three real alternatives so you can see where the trade-offs hit.
Product
Price Range
Key Strength
Key Weakness
Best For
Earth Rated Poop Bags (Lavender, 270 ct)
Mid (~$15)
Thick, leak-proof build with a noticeable lavender scent that masks odor
Scent can be cloying if you’re sensitive; lavender oil fades over time
Owners who want reliable leak protection and don’t mind a floral cover-up
Amazon Basics Poop Bags (300 ct)
Budget (~$9)
Cheapest per bag; no-frills basics that get the job done
Thinner plastic, occasional tearing, zero odor control beyond the bag itself
Anyone on a tight budget who picks up waste immediately and doesn’t store bags
Pogi’s Poop Bags (300 ct, Unscented)
Mid–High (~$20)
Activated charcoal layers actually trap odor instead of masking it
Pricier per bag; rolls can be stiff to tear off in cold weather
People who hate artificial scents and want genuine odor containment in the can
PetSafe Poop Bags (300 ct, Unscented)
Budget–Mid (~$12)
Consistent thickness and a large roll size for the price
No scent option; edges can feel rough against fingers when tearing
Value hunters who prefer unscented and trust a big pet brand’s QC
Earth Rated poop bags vs Amazon Basics Poop Bags
The price gap is real: Amazon Basics will run you about $9 for 300 bags, while Earth Rated’s 270-count lavender pack comes to $15. That’s nearly double the cost per bag. But you’ll feel the difference the first time you pick up something wet or mushy. Amazon Basics bags are noticeably thinner—they’ll hold a firm solid, but any moisture or sharp kibble bits can push through if you’re not careful. Earth Rated uses a thicker film that’s genuinely leak-proof; I’ve dragged a half-digested tennis ball out of grass with one and nothing came through. The lavender scent on Earth Rated also means you can tie off a bag and drop it in a hallway bin without the room smelling like a kennel. Amazon Basics gives you zero odor help. So if money is tight and you pick up every time without delay, Amazon Basics works. If you hate the thought of a split bag ruining your afternoon, or you want that lavender buffer, Earth Rated is worth the extra $6.
Earth Rated vs Pogi’s Poop Bags
This is the most interesting comparison for anyone shopping best dog poop bags for odor control. Pogi’s uses activated charcoal embedded in the plastic, which actually neutralizes smell rather than covering it. Earth Rated’s lavender is an added fragrance—it masks the odor while the bag is fresh, but after a day or two in a closed can the lavender fades and the underlying smell can creep back. Pogi’s bags keep working until you empty the bin. The trade-off? Pogi’s runs pricier (around $20 for 300 bags) and the charcoal can make the plastic feel a little dustier out of the roll. Also, some people find the charcoal smell mildly weird. Earth Rated’s lavender is more pleasant out of the box, and the bag texture is silky-smooth, with a reliable tear-off perforation that never leaves you fighting a stubborn roll.
Which one you pick depends on your routine. If you take the bagged waste straight to an outside bin, Earth Rated’s lavender is enough and more pleasant to carry. If you knot the bag and let it sit in a kitchen trash can for a day or two, Pogi’s charcoal is the smarter buy.
Earth Rated vs PetSafe Poop Bags
PetSafe is the quiet contender in this category. They charge about $12 for 300 unscented bags—close to Amazon Basics territory but with noticeably better construction. The plastic is thick enough that I’ve never had a leak, and the roll fits the same cheap dispenser most of us already own. At $3 less than Earth Rated for 30 more bags, PetSafe looks solid on paper. What you give up is any scent. No lavender, no odor mask. The bags are just plain black plastic, and they don’t try to hide what’s inside. For a lot of walkers that’s fine. But if you live in a small apartment or share a building hallway, the absence of any odor-assist becomes obvious fast. Earth Rated’s lavender gives you that extra bit of politeness—the same reason people buy scented trash bags for their kitchen. PetSafe is the better deal if you already have a scent strategy (like a sealed bin). Earth Rated wins if you want a bag that smells like a dryer sheet when you tie it off.
So, is Earth Rated poop bags worth it? For most owners who prioritize leak-proof reliability and a mild scent to keep things civil, yes. The lavender version is a specific product—if you hate floral smells, skip it and go for Pogi’s unscented charcoal bags instead. And if you’re on a strict budget and don’t mind a thinner bag with no odor control, Amazon Basics will save you a few dollars. But if you want the sweet spot of durability, that fresh-lavender moment on the walk, and a brand that actually backs its rolls with consistent quality, Earth Rated’s 270-count refill is the pick.
Ready to decide on the Earth Rated poop bags?
See today’s price, stock and delivery options on Amazon.
