This Maybelline Sky High mascara review answers the question you actually care about: is it worth nine dollars? Yes, if you want real length without spending on a lash lift. The washable formula lengthens and volumizes with each coat, and the blackest black shade gives your lashes definition that actually shows. It’s not for heavy volume, but for length and separation, it delivers.
Provides exceptional performance at an accessible price point.
Price vs. rivals
Typical
CheaperTypicalPricier
Priced competitively within the drugstore mascara segment, this Maybelline product is at the typical mid-range for popular alternatives, neither notably cheap nor expensive.
Ease of use
Excellent 88/100
The mascara's buildable formula and washable design make it easy to apply and remove, contributing to a straightforward user experience.
Overview of the Maybelline Sky High Mascara
This is Maybelline’s answer to “I want long lashes without falsies.” It’s a buildable formula drugstore mascara that relies on a flexible, tapered wand and a lightweight wax-based formula to stretch each lash upward. The tube holds 7.2 ml of product, which is standard for the category.
It solves the problem of lashes that just won’t show. If yours are straight, short, or point downward, the wand helps lift and define. It’s meant for daily wear, not a nightclub look, though you can layer it for more drama. The “blackest black” shade means one coat is enough for most people to see a difference.
Key Features of the Maybelline Sky High Mascara
Flexible tapered wand – The wand bends slightly as you brush, which lets you get closer to the lash line without poking your eye. It also fans lashes outward as you wiggle upward.
Buildable wax-based formula – You can apply one coat for a natural look or two to three for noticeable length. It dries fast, so you don’t have to wait forever between layers.
Blackest black shade – This is one of the darker blacks in the drugstore aisle. It doesn’t look gray or washed out after a few hours, which matters if your lashes are light or sparse.
Washable formula – Comes off with warm water and gentle cleanser. No oil cleanser needed, no scrubbing your eyes raw. That’s a relief for anyone who hates the “raccoon eye” the morning after forgetting a waterproof remover.
Multiplying effect – The formula contains microfibers that cling to each lash. You get the look of more lashes rather than just thicker ones. It’s a subtle difference, but it shows in photos.
Fit for You
You have short, straight lashes that point down and you want a lift without a curler.
You wear glasses and need mascara that makes your lashes visible above the frames without smudging the lenses.
You commute or work long hours and need a mascara that stays put through a nine-to-five without flaking into your eyes.
You’re new to mascara or only wear it a few times a week and don’t want to spend twenty bucks on a tube that expires in three months.
You prefer a natural look during the day but want the option to build it up for evenings without switching products.
Uses
A regular workday is where it shines. One coat in the morning, no touch-ups needed, and your lashes still look defined when you leave. The formula doesn’t transfer onto your lower lid after a few hours, which is a common complaint with volumizing mascaras.
For a night out, two coats give you length that reads as “Did you get lash extensions?” The wand catches the inner and outer corner lashes better than a straight brush does, so you don’t miss those short ones near the tear duct.
It also works well if you curl your lashes first. The lightweight wax holds the curl without weighing it back down. That combination—curler plus Sky High—is the closest most people will get to a lash lift at a drugstore price.
Experience with Maybelline Sky High Mascara
The wand is where the magic lives. It’s skinny and comb-like, with bristles that are short enough to grab tiny lashes. You don’t get a ton of product on the brush, so your first coat looks subtle. That’s intentional—you build from there.
The formula feels wet at first but sets within about thirty seconds. That means you have to work fast if you want multiple coats. If you wait too long between layers, the second coat can get a little clumpy. A quick wiggle at the base and a pull-through motion solves it.
Throughout the day, the mascara stays flexible. Your lashes don’t feel stiff or crunchy when you blink. That’s a big deal if you’ve ever worn a mascara that made you aware of your own eyelids by noon. Removal is straightforward: warm water and a gentle cleanser take it off in about twenty seconds. No tugging, no lost lashes.
One annoyance: the tube dries out faster than some competitors. After about two months, the formula gets thicker and harder to spread. You’ll know it’s time to replace it when the first coat starts looking clumpy rather than defined. At nine bucks, it’s not a tragedy, but it’s worth noting.
Pros and Cons
Pros
Noticeable length – Even one coat makes short lashes look longer. The microfibers actually do their job without falling into your eyes.
Flexible wand reaches every lash – The tapered tip catches the inner corner and lower lashes. You won’t miss the tiny ones.
Stays put through a workday – No flaking, no smudging under the eyes. It holds up to blinking, humidity, and accidental eye rubbing.
Easy removal with a splash of water – You don’t need a special remover or a lot of elbow grease. That saves time and skin.
Price is fair for the performance – Under ten dollars for a mascara that competes with tubes twice its price. It’s a solid value.
Cons
Volume is modest – This is not a mascara that gives you thick, dramatic lashes. If you want density, you’ll need to layer multiple coats or use a different product.
Dries out faster than average – After two months, the formula thickens. You can add a drop of contact solution to revive it, but you shouldn’t have to.
Wand can get messy – The flexible wand picks up a lot of product on the tip. You’ll want to wipe it on the tube edge before each use to avoid blobs.
Second coat needs timing – If you wait too long between layers, the formula clumps. You have to work in quick succession, which takes some practice.
Not ideal for very oily lids – Some users report minor smudging on the lower lash line after eight hours if their skin is particularly oily. A setting powder underneath fixes it.
Advantages
Maybelline Sky High vs Lash Sensational mascara – Lash Sensational gives you more volume with its curved wand, while Sky High focuses on length and separation. If you can only pick one, think about whether you want drama or definition. Sky High wins if your goal is to show off every lash.
Washable formula that performs like a waterproof – Many washable mascaras run by hour four. This one holds the curl and the color without the struggle of a waterproof tube at removal time.
Consistent results without a curler – The wand and formula work together to lift lashes. You don’t need an extra step in your morning routine to see a difference.
Buildable without turning into a mess – The thin formula layers cleanly up to three coats. That’s rare for a drugstore mascara, where stacking usually means crunchy, spidery lashes.
Who Should Buy the Maybelline Sky High Mascara
Buy it if you want length that looks natural and lasts. It’s especially good for people with short, straight lashes who want definition without falsies.
Buy it if you’re on a budget and don’t want to sacrifice performance. It beats many prestige mascaras in the same category.
Buy it if you dislike the hassle of waterproof mascara removal. This comes off easily with regular cleanser.
Skip it if you need heavy volume. Look for a mascara with a thicker, creamier formula and a fluffy wand. The Lash Sensational original is a better bet for density.
Skip it if you have very oily lids or live in a humid climate. Waterproof versions exist for that situation, and they hold up better.
FAQ
Is the Maybelline Sky High Mascara worth it?
Yes, for under ten dollars, it delivers length and definition that rivals pricier options. The flexible wand and buildable formula make it a reliable daily driver, especially if your main goal is longer-looking lashes.
How long does Maybelline Sky High mascara last before drying out?
Expect about two months of consistent performance. After that, the formula thickens and becomes harder to spread. You can extend its life by storing the tube upright and closing it tightly after each use.
Is Maybelline Sky High mascara safe for sensitive eyes?
Most users with sensitive eyes report no issues. The formula is fragrance-free and ophthalmologist-tested. If you have extreme sensitivities, do a patch test on your wrist first, since everyone’s tolerance is different.
Does Maybelline Sky High mascara smudge during the day?
It holds up well for most people through a standard workday. Those with very oily eyelids may see minor transfer after eight hours. A light dusting of translucent powder under the lower lashes usually solves that.
How do you remove Maybelline Sky High mascara without damaging lashes?
Use warm water and a gentle cleanser. Apply a small amount to your fingertips, massage the lashes for about twenty seconds, then rinse. No rubbing or tugging needed, which helps keep your natural lashes healthy.
Is Maybelline Sky High mascara good for short lashes?
Yes, it’s one of the better drugstore options for short lashes. The skinny wand reaches the base of even tiny lashes, and the microfibers add noticeable length. One coat gives a visible lift, and two coats make short lashes look more prominent.
Final Verdict
The Maybelline Sky High mascara is a smart buy for anyone who prioritizes length and natural-looking definition. It does one thing well—making lashes look longer—and it does it without the typical drugstore mascara downsides like flaking, smudging, or difficult removal. For nine dollars, that’s a fair trade.
The one thing to keep in mind: it’s not a volumizing mascara. If you want thick, fluffy lashes, look elsewhere. But if length is your goal, this is the best mascara for length and volume in its price range.
Maybelline Sky High Mascara vs the Alternatives Worth Your Money in 2026
In the drugstore lash aisle, Maybelline Sky High has carved out a real niche—cheap enough to grab on a whim, but serious about length and volume. It’s the washable version (no wrestling with stubborn tubing), and the “blackest black” shade delivers that heavy-lidded contrast without flaking halfway through your afternoon. At around $9, it sits right in the sweet spot between budget and mid-range. But is it actually the best mascara for length and volume at this price? Against three heavy hitters—L’Oréal Lash Paradise, CoverGirl Lash Blast Volume, and Essence Lash Princess—it’s not a clean sweep.
Product
Price Range
Key Strength
Key Weakness
Best For
Maybelline Sky High Mascara
~$9
Buildable formula that lengthens without clumping; flexible wand works tiny corner lashes
Volume fades after 6 hours; can look spidery if you layer too fast
Someone who wants dramatic length with moderate volume, willing to reapply for evening
L’Oréal Lash Paradise
~$11
Thick, fluffy volume in one coat; holds curl all day
Wet formula dries flaky by hour 10; tube dries out fast
Dense, full-lash looks without multiple coats
CoverGirl Lash Blast Volume
~$10
Dry, sculpting formula that separates; the rubber comb is impossible to mess up
Length is average at best; won’t touch your brow bone
Beginners or anyone who wants defined, separated lashes with zero clumps
Essence Lash Princess (Sculpted Volume)
~$5
Unreal volume for the price; blackest black with a glossy finish
Wand is flimsy and drags; formula gets gloppy after one month
Budget-first shoppers who replace mascara every 3–4 weeks
Maybelline Sky High Mascara vs L’Oréal Lash Paradise
L’Oréal Lash Paradise is the volume queen. One coat and your lashes look like you’re wearing half a set of falsies. But that wet, creamy formula is a double-edged sword: you can’t reapply without it turning gunky, and by hour ten you’ll spot little black flecks under your eyes. Sky High is drier from the start, so you can layer it two or three times without hitting glue-ball territory. The trade-off? Volume. Even three coats of Sky High won’t match what Lash Paradise does in one. So if your priority is maximum volume fast, grab the L’Oréal and accept the flaking. If you prefer a buildable formula mascara drugstore that stays clean all day, Sky High wins.
Maybelline Sky High Mascara vs CoverGirl Lash Blast Volume
CoverGirl Lash Blast is the boring, reliable sibling. Its rubber comb separates each lash so cleanly that you could wear it to a job interview without anyone noticing. But that same comb struggles to grab the tiny lashes in your inner corner—you end up with a bald spot unless you angle the wand like a contortionist. Sky High’s tapered, flexible wand fixes that exact annoyance. It hugs the curve of your eye, coating those micro-lashes without stabbing yourself. On the other hand, Sky High’s formula gets fluffier (read: less precise) after a few layers, while Lash Blast stays crisp. So if you’re after separated, natural-looking length and don’t mind a slightly longer application, Sky High is the more versatile pick. If you just want a no-brainer, grab-and-go that won’t smudge during a crying jag, CoverGirl has your back.
Maybelline Sky High Mascara vs Essence Lash Princess
Essence Lash Princess costs half the price and delivers a volume that borders on comical. For $5, you get dramatic, glossy black lashes that look like tarantula legs—if that’s your vibe, great. But the wand is a floppy plastic piece that tugs, and the formula thickens noticeably after three weeks, turning into a clumpy mess. Sky High’s wand feels sturdier, it doesn’t pull at your lash line, and the tube stays fresh for a solid two months. If you’re asking yourself is Maybelline Sky High mascara worth it compared to Essence, the answer is yes if you want a washable mascara that lengthens and volumizes without degrading in a month. But if you change mascaras every five weeks and hate spending more than a latte, Essence is the budget champion—just replace it often.
Who should buy Maybelline Sky High? Anyone who wants a best mascara for length and volume that doesn’t force you to choose—it gives you decent amounts of both, with a buildable formula that lets you dial it up or down. If you have straight lashes that need curling, this holds a curl fine but not as well as heated lash curlers. For that reason, if you rely on waterproof hold or need all-day humidity resistance, skip Sky High and go for L’Oréal Lash Paradise waterproof instead. Otherwise, at $9, it’s the most flexible all-rounder on the shelf.
Ready to decide on the Maybelline Sky High Mascara?
See today’s price, stock and delivery options on Amazon.
