The crossover theme adds collectibility but the higher price reduces value-for-money compared to standard commander decks.
Price vs. rivals
Pricier
CheaperTypicalPricier
Priced above average for preconstructed Commander decks, reflecting its premium crossover theme and limited appeal compared to standard releases.
Ease of use
Poor 25/100
The game's complex rules, specialized terminology, and strategic depth make it very challenging for an average person unfamiliar with Magic: The Gathering.
Overview
This is the We Are the Borg Commander deck from Magic: The Gathering’s crossover with Star Trek. It’s a preconstructed deck built around a Borg-themed strategy—assimilating your opponents’ creatures and using them against their owners. If you’re a Trekkie who also plays Commander, this is the deck that lets you live the “resistance is futile” fantasy without having to build from scratch. The problem it solves? You want a themed deck that actually plays well out of the box, not just a pile of cards with a cool name. It’s aimed at two types of people: collectors who love Star Trek crossovers, and budget-minded Commander players who want a playable deck with a clear, aggressive game plan. At $72.01, it sits right in the sweet spot for a premium preconstructed deck—not cheap, but far from the $150+ premium sets.
Key Features
Assimilate mechanic: You can steal your opponents’ permanents and get bonuses for controlling things that aren’t yours. It’s the core of the deck and makes every game feel like a slow takeover.
Borg-themed Commander, Seven of Nine: She gives you a way to turn your stolen cards into threats, and her abilities reward you for having a mix of creature types. Expect to play a lot of weird tribal synergy.
60-card deck with a clear upgrade path: The stock list is solid, but you can swap in more theft effects, extra counterspells, or better mana rocks without breaking the theme. It’s a great base for tuning.
Premium card stock and foil treatment: The face commander and several key cards are in foil. Owners tend to mention the printing quality is noticeably better than some standard Commander decks—less curl, more shine.
Includes a Collector’s Booster sample pack: You get one pack from the Star Trek: The Universe Beyond series. It’s a small bonus, but the lottery of getting a super-rare crossover card is real.
Ready to play in under two minutes: Shuffle, draw seven, and go. The mana curve is designed to avoid those “stuck on three lands” frustrations that plague casual tables.
Fit for You
You’re a Star Trek fan who wants to bring the Borg to your Friday night Commander group and still be competitive in casual games.
You already own a few Commander decks but don’t want to spend hours tweaking a list for a theme night.
You like the idea of stealing your opponent’s biggest creature and turning it against them—and you’re okay with making enemies.
You appreciate a deck that has a clear “take over the board” strategy instead of five different combos that never come together.
You’re a collector who wants a full-art, foil Commander that looks amazing in a top loader.
You’re new to Commander and want a deck that teaches you how to play a tempo-control archetype without being too complicated.
Uses
Pull this out against a table of tribal decks—Elves, Goblins, Dragons—and you’ll have a field day stealing their best creatures. The Borg theme shines when you can actually take control of an opponent’s Lord and start buffing your own stolen board. It’s also a fun deck for low-power competitive events where theft is allowed, because it creates memorable moments (“Wait, you’re using my own Ulamog against me?”).
For casual multiplayer games, expect to get targeted early. The Borg aren’t subtle, and once you start assimilating, everyone at the table learns why resistance is futile. That’s part of the charm, though—it’s a villain deck that forces interesting political decisions.
Experience
Opening the box, you get a sturdy deck box (not the flimsy cardboard kind), a life pad, and a few tokens. The cards feel good in the hand—no factory-fresh smell of cheap ink. Setup is trivial: open the plastic, shuffle, and you’re playing. The mana base is the first thing you’ll notice: it’s heavy on blue and black, with a splash of colorless. That means you’ll have to pay attention to your lands, because the deck wants a lot of blue to counter spells and a lot of black for creature removal.
Here’s the honest annoyance: the deck includes a few cards that are just “good stuff” rather than Borg-flavored. You might wish every card had Star Trek art, but they don’t. The crossover flavor is strong on the commanders and about a third of the spells—the rest are generic Magic cards that happen to fit the strategy. It’s a small letdown if you’re a purist, but from a gameplay perspective, it works.
Games take a while because theft-based decks generate extra decisions—do I steal the Sol Ring or the Craterhoof? Expect your turns to be a bit longer than average. The deck also lacks instant-speed removal for artifacts, which can leave you vulnerable to combo players who assemble a win on the stack. That’s the trade-off: you’re built to steal, not to destroy.
Pros and Cons
Pros
Strong theme execution: The Borg feel present—you really do take over the game piece by piece. The artwork on the face commander is gorgeous.
Playable out of the box: You can bring this to a casual Commander night and win a fair share of games without upgrades.
Great value for the price: At $72, you get a foil commander, a Collector’s Booster, and a deck that costs less than the sum of its singles in most markets.
Easy to upgrade: The decklist has clear slots where you can swap in more efficient counterspells or better mana rocks. The Borg commander decklist online is a good starting point for those changes.
Collector appeal: If you’re looking for the best Star Trek crossover deck for collectors, this is it. The other crossover decks don’t have as cohesive a mechanic.
Cons
Not full Star Trek art: About a third of the cards have generic Magic art. If you want the whole deck to look like Star Trek screenshots, you’ll be disappointed.
Slower than aggro decks: You’ll often spend the first four turns setting up the engine, which can lose you games against fast creature-based strategies.
Weak against graveyard hate: If an opponent plays Rest in Peace or Leyline of the Void, your theft plan stalls hard. There’s no built-in way to deal with that in the stock list.
Mana base is a bit clunky: The deck uses a lot of taplands and basics, which can leave you a turn behind. A mana crypt or better duals would help, but that’s an expensive fix.
High salt factor: Some players hate theft mechanics. Expect groans and occasional “can I have my card back?” after the game. It’s a deck you play with friends who are okay with it.
Advantages
Compared to other preconstructed Commander decks at this price point, the Borg deck has a more focused theme than most. It doesn’t try to be five things at once—it’s a theft deck, full stop. That focus gives it a higher Borg commander power level than a typical preconstructed deck from the same era, which often suffer from split identities. Against Borg Commander deck alternatives like generic Dimir control decks or other crossover products (e.g., the Warhammer 40k decks), this one feels more unique because the mechanic is a direct translation of the source material. Nobody else makes you say “Your creature will adapt to service us” when you steal a Ghalta.
Who Should Buy
Star Trek fans looking for a playable theme deck. This is your jam. You’ll enjoy the flavor, and you can still win games.
Commander players who want a theft deck without building from scratch. You’ll save money and time.
Collectors who missed the first run of Universes Beyond crossover decks. The Borg set is a solid addition to a shelf display.
Skip it if you hate theft mechanics. You’ll frustrate opponents and probably yourself. Look at a tribal deck or a spellslinger preconstructed instead—something like the “Exit from Exile” or “Draconic Rage” are more straightforward.
Skip it if you want a high-power Commander deck to compete with cEDH tables. This is not that. It’s tuned for casual games, and the Borg commander power level sits at around a 6 out of 10 on the typical scale.
FAQ
Is the MTG Borg Commander deck worth it?
Yes, if you want a fun, themed Commander deck that plays well out of the box and doesn’t cost a fortune. The value in singles plus the Collector’s Booster makes it a fair deal at $72.
What is the MTG Star Trek deck features that make it special?
The standout feature is the Assimilate keyword, which lets you steal permanents and get bonuses for controlling things you don’t own. The foil commander and Star Trek art on key cards are the other big draws.
How strong is the Borg commander power level?
It’s a solid casual deck, roughly a 6 out of 10. It can dominate a low-power table but will struggle against tuned midrange or combo decks. Upgrades can push it to a 7 or 8.
What Borg Commander deck alternatives exist?
If you want a similar theme, look at the “Tempt with Discovery” or “Gonti, Lord of Luxury” builds. For other crossover decks, the Warhammer 40k Necron Dynasties deck also has a steal-and-reanimate feel.
Can I play this deck in a tournament?
Yes, but only in casual Commander pods. It’s not competitive for cEDH because it’s too slow and lacks efficient interaction. You could try it in a budget tournament, but expect to lose to faster decks.
Does the deck come with a full Borg commander decklist printed?
Yes, the insert includes a list of all 100 cards. You can also find it online easily. The list is public, so you can check it before buying if you want to see specific cards.
Final Verdict
If you love Star Trek and play Commander, the MTG Borg Commander review boils down to one thing: this is the most satisfying crossover deck for fans who actually want to play, not just collect. The strategy is clear, the theme sticks, and the price makes sense for what you get. Just know that it’s not a powerhouse—it’s a deck for a fun night with beer and pretzels, where the goal is to hear someone yell “Resistance is futile” at the table. That’s worth seventy-two bucks.
MTG Borg Commander Deck vs the Competition in 2026
If you’re here, you’re probably wondering whether the new Star Trek crossover deck—We Are the Borg—actually plays well, or if it’s just a collector’s trinket in a box. It’s priced at $72.01, which puts it right in the middle of the current Commander deck market. But the real question is: does it beat the other Universes Beyond heavyweights? This MTG Borg Commander review will walk you through three real alternatives—Warhammer 40k’s Necron Dynasties, Doctor Who’s Timey-Wimey, and Lord of the Rings’ Sauron—and help you decide if this is the best Star Trek crossover deck for collectors, or if you should look at Borg Commander deck alternatives instead.
Product
Price Range
Key Strength
Key Weakness
Best For
MTG Borg Commander Deck
~$72
Unique Assemble mechanic and flavorful Assimilation cards
Power level is moderate; relies on combat tricks more than raw ramp
Star Trek fans who want a fun, thematic deck with some new keyword action
Warhammer 40k – Necron Dynasties
~$65–$75
Strong recursion engine and artifact synergy
Plays slowly out of the box; games can drag
Players who like grindy, value-oriented graveyard strategies
Doctor Who – Timey-Wimey
~$70–$80
Time travel suspend triggers and instant-speed shenanigans
Can be confusing to pilot; lots of upkeep tracking
Spell-slingers who love chaos and unpredictable turns
LOTR – Sauron, the Dark Lord
~$80–$90
Amass Orcs army token generation is straightforward and powerful
Lacks interaction; very linear game plan
Timmy-style players who want to smash face with a growing token army
MTG Borg Commander Deck vs Warhammer 40k Necron Dynasties
Both are sci-fi crossover decks, but they play completely differently. The Necron Dynasties deck is all about bringing stuff back from the graveyard—you’ll see the same creatures recur over and over, and it’s tough to shut down. The Borg deck, by contrast, wants to tap your opponents’ creatures and steal them via Assimilate counters. That’s a neat trick, but you have to actually connect in combat first. Against a board full of 1/1 tokens, it’s fine. Against Necron’s chunky artifact creatures you’ll struggle. If you’re asking “Is MTG Borg Commander deck worth buying” for a more interactive, control-ish feel, then yes—but Necron is better for players who love a resilient engine. The Borg commander deck power level is a notch below Necron’s if you’re playing purely for wins, though the flavor of assimilating your opponent’s Wurmcoil Engine is hard to beat.
MTG Borg Commander Deck vs Doctor Who Timey-Wimey
Timey-Wimey is the wild card of the bunch. It runs suspend cards, time counters, and cards that care about turns taken—you’ll sometimes take three extra turns in a row, then lose because you forgot to exile something. The Borg deck is more straightforward: play big artifacts, tap down blockers, swing, assimilate. Where the Doctor Who deck feels like a Rubik’s Cube that explodes, the Borg deck feels like a hydraulic press—steady, methodical, and inevitable. If you’re looking for a Borg Commander deck alternative that rewards careful sequencing and a bit of math, Timey-Wimey is your weird cousin. But if you just want to feel like a villain slowly taking over the game, the Borg deck does that better. Also, the MTG Star Trek deck features a single new keyword (Assimilate) and a cool 12-card bonus sheet, which is more cohesive than the scatter-shot mechanics in the Doctor Who deck.
MTG Borg Commander Deck vs LOTR Sauron, the Dark Lord
This is the most direct comparison for raw power. Sauron’s deck makes Orc tokens every time you cast a spell with Amass, and you can easily have a 30/30 army by turn five. The Borg deck can’t compete on that timeline. What the Borg deck has, though, is interaction. You’ve got removal, board wipes, and ways to steal key pieces. Sauron just runs you over. If you want to win quick and don’t care about subtlety, grab Sauron. If you want a deck that feels like you’re outsmarting your opponents one creature at a time—and you enjoy the flavor of turning their own swords against them—the Borg deck is the smarter pick. It’s also a lot more interesting to pilot across multiple games, which matters if you plan to keep this as your main deck for a while. And if you’re hunting the best Star Trek crossover deck for collectors, this one wins hands-down: the art is gorgeous, the alternate-frame cards are exclusive, and the Borg commander decklist includes cards you won’t find anywhere else.
So who should buy the MTG Borg Commander Deck? If you’re a Star Trek fan who loves control and theft strategies, and you’re okay with a deck that wins through careful accumulation rather than explosive combos, grab it. If you absolutely need the highest power level for competitive Commander nights, the Sauron or Necron decks will give you a better win rate. And if you’re looking for a Borg Commander deck alternative that is pure chaos—and you don’t mind keeping track of six different triggers each turn—the Doctor Who deck is where it’s at. For everyone else, this is a solid, flavorful, mid-power deck that’s genuinely fun to play right out of the box. That’s rare for a crossover product, and it makes the Borg deck worth the ticket price.
Ready to decide on the MTG Borg Commander Deck?
See today’s price, stock and delivery options on Amazon.
